{"id":105976,"date":"2022-01-12T13:39:07","date_gmt":"2022-01-12T12:39:07","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/?p=105976"},"modified":"2022-01-14T16:51:50","modified_gmt":"2022-01-14T15:51:50","slug":"il-kumitat-4-dawk-li-ser-isalvaw-lill-gvern-mill-marda-mxajtna-tal-liberta-tal-kelma","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/2022\/01\/il-kumitat-4-dawk-li-ser-isalvaw-lill-gvern-mill-marda-mxajtna-tal-liberta-tal-kelma\/","title":{"rendered":"Il-“Kumitat” (4): dawk li ser “isalvaw” lill-gvern mill-marda mxajtna tal-libert\u00e0 tal-kelma"},"content":{"rendered":"

\"\"<\/p>\n

\u017bew\u0121 letturi universitarji huma membri tal-kumitat ma\u0127tur mill-gvern sitt xhur wara li xxandru l-konklu\u017cjonijiet tal-Im\u0127allfin tal-inkjesta dwar il-qtil ta’ Daphne Caruana Galizia biex jipproponi “\u017cviluppi” g\u0127all-qasam tal-\u0121urnali\u017cmu f’Malta.<\/a><\/p>\n

Il-fehmiet ta’ dawn it-tnejn huma mag\u0127rufin sewwa l-opinjonijiet, u g\u0127aldaqstant wie\u0127ed jista’ jikkonkludi li ntag\u0127\u017clu g\u0127al fuq il-kumitat li suppost g\u0127andu jwettaq ir-rakkomandazzjonijiet tal-Im\u0127allfin tal-inkjesta appuntu g\u0127aliex ma jaqblux mar-rakkomandazzjonijiet tal-Im\u0127allfin.<\/p>\n

Il-\u0127atra ta’ Saviour Balzan setg\u0127et saret biex ji\u0121i redikolat il-pro\u010bess jew g\u0127allinqas biex tg\u0127arrqu f’ironija insopportabbli.<\/a> I\u017cda l-\u0127atra ta’ Carmen Sammut u ta’ Saviour Formosa saret bil-g\u0127an li timmina l-pro\u010bess kollu.<\/p>\n

Ejjew nag\u0127tu daqqa t’g\u0127ajn lejn artiklu li kitbet Carmen Sammut fl-2019 f’\u0121urnal f’Tel Aviv.<\/p>\n

L-artiklu tbajjad b’ti\u010bpisa akkademika i\u017cda fil-verit\u00e0 huwa biss ripetizzjoni miktub b’lingwa\u0121\u0121 ifjen tal-litanija tal-One TV li Daphne Caruana Galizija bil-kitbiet tag\u0127ha kienet twe\u0121\u0121a’ u ta\u0127qar lin-nies, li kienet mostru elitista li kienet tintag\u0127raf minn Friedrich Engels, li Joseph Muscat huwa nadif u vittma patetika tad-“demonizzazzjoni” u li l-idea li l-libert\u00e0 tal-istampa f’Malta tinsab mhedda hija biss qlajja’ ta’ Matthew Caruana Galizia u ta’ s\u0127abu, liema qlajja’ irnexxielhom ibellg\u0127uha lil dawk i\u010b-\u010bwie\u010b ta’ The New York Times, The Guardian, La Repubblica<\/em> u gazzetti o\u0127ra b\u0127alhom ma jifhmux akka dwar il-\u0121urnali\u017cmu u dwar il-libert\u00e0 tal-istampa.<\/p>\n

Forsi qed ta\u0127sbu li qed inkabbarhom u li m’iniex qed inkun \u0121ust. Ti\u017cbaljaw jekk ta\u0127sbu b’dan il-mod. I\u010b\u010bekkjaw g\u0127all-affari tag\u0127kom. Din Carmen kienet kitbet kapitlu li j\u0121ib l-isem Media, Freedom of Speech and Democracy in the EU and beyond.<\/em> Intom u tqallbu g\u0127andkom issibu research paper numru 10 li fiha bejn wie\u0127ed u ie\u0127or 158 pa\u0121na. U l-artiklu ta’ Carmen Sammut jasal biex iqallag\u0127lek l-istonku.<\/p>\n

Il-kelma “gidba” ma ssibha mkien. I\u017cda tg\u0127id li kienet biss “narrativa” l-idea li Daphne nqatlet g\u0127ax \u0127admet ta’ \u0121urnalista u li l-qtil tag\u0127ha kien ri\u017cultat tal-fatt li l-libert\u00e0 tal-istampa f’Malta tinsab mhedda. Il-kelma ‘narrattiva’ hija biss kelma pulita u\u017cata mill-akkademi\u010bi. F’dan il-kuntest il-kelma ‘narrattiva’ ma tfissirx storja i\u017cda tfisser storja li mhix vera jew li hi vvintata. G\u0127alhekk iva, skont Carmen Sammut, l-idea li Daphne nqatlet u g\u0127aldaqstant je\u0127tie\u0121 li ti\u0121i indirizzata t-tema tal-libert\u00e0 tal-istampa hi, minnha nfisha, gidba.<\/p>\n

Dan huwa l-oppost ta’ dak li kkonkludew l-Im\u0127allfin tal-inkjesta dwar il-qtil ta’ Daphne. Huwa wkoll mod kif il-gvern ikun jista’ jserra\u0127 mo\u0127\u0127u li r-restrizzjonijiet li je\u017cistu f’Malta fuq il-libert\u00e0 tal-istampa, mhux talli jibqg\u0127u bla mittiefsa, i\u017cda sa\u0127ansitra jkomplu jissa\u0127\u0127u bl-isku\u017ca ta’ “araw, waqqafna Kumitat ta’ Esperti!”<\/p>\n

Dan li \u0121ej huwa ftit mill-g\u0127erf li kienet \u0127ar\u0121et bih fl-artiklu:<\/p>\n