{"id":111232,"date":"2022-08-25T10:58:07","date_gmt":"2022-08-25T08:58:07","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/?p=111232"},"modified":"2022-09-01T17:45:30","modified_gmt":"2022-09-01T15:45:30","slug":"hbieb-jew-ghedewwa","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/2022\/08\/hbieb-jew-ghedewwa\/","title":{"rendered":"\u0126bieb jew g\u0127edewwa?"},"content":{"rendered":"

\"\"<\/p>\n

Ikkritikajt lil Joe Giglio u, b’mod impli\u010bitu lil Alex Borg, g\u0127all-istqarrija li \u0127are\u0121 il-PN u li permezz tag\u0127ha ppropona li biex jinstab tarf g\u0127all-problemi marbutin mas-sigurt\u00e0 fil-pajji\u017c, je\u0127tie\u0121 li b’mod “immedjat” jitke\u010b\u010bew dawk il-barranin li jwettqu delitt u jiksru l-li\u0121ijiet tal-pajji\u017c.<\/a><\/p>\n

Il-kliem vag u iebes u n-natura intrinsikament diskriminatorja ta’ din l-istqarrija turi li hi stqarrija ta’ bixra razzista. Meta \u017c\u017cid mag\u0127ha l-proposta l-o\u0127ra li g\u0127andha tintu\u017ca l-armata biex tissorvelja t-toroq fin-nuqqas ta’ xi forma ta’ stat ta’ emer\u0121enza, t-ton u l-intenzjoni faxxista jidhru aktar \u010bari.<\/p>\n

Aktar tard, Bernard Grech re\u0121\u0121a’ lura wa\u0127da mill-proposti hu u jistqarr li ma jaqbilx mar-retorika ta’ “Maltin kontra l-barranin”.<\/a><\/p>\n

Hemm sinifikat akbar f’dik il-kwotazzjoni. Tabil\u0127aqq l-istqarrija ta’ Giglio u Borg xebb\u0127et kwistjonijiet marbutin mas-sigurt\u00e0 ma’ konfrontazzjoni bejn ir-razez. Ta’ min ig\u0127id li \u017c-\u017cew\u0121 kelliema kienu qed jirrea\u0121ixxu g\u0127all-\u0121lieda li nqalg\u0127et fi triq fil-\u0126amrun bejn numru ta’ barranin. Kif \u0127abat, dawn huma nies li telqu mis-Sirja biex ja\u0127arbu minn gwerra mdemmija.<\/p>\n

Ftit sig\u0127at wara meta xxandar il-filmat ta’ \u0121lieda \u0127arxa fit-toroq ta’ Paceville.<\/a> \u0127add ma kien feta\u0127 \u0127alqu. Dakinhar ma taw ebda \u0127jiel li kienu ser jinsistu fuq it-tke\u010b\u010bijiet “immedjati” ta’ dawk involuti. Jistg\u0127u forsi jwie\u0121bu li b’daqshekk ma jfissirx li huma razzisti. Fil-fatt hekk hu g\u0127ax jidher li qed jipproponu politika li tinbidel skont in-nazzjonalit\u00e0 ta’ min ikun kiser il-li\u0121i.<\/p>\n

Anki jekk stess na\u010b\u010bettaw l-argument tag\u0127hom li huma m’humiex razzisti, xorta wa\u0127da nsibu li qed jiddiskriminaw g\u0127al ra\u0121unijiet o\u0127ra li m’humiex dikjarati. Jista’ jkun li forsi g\u0127aliex ma kienx hemm g\u0127ag\u0127a pubblika kontra dak li stqarrew, jew forsi g\u0127aliex x-xorb li kienu xorbu dawk involuti inxtara minn stabbiliment ta’ klijent ta’ wie\u0127ed mill-Membri Parlamentari?<\/p>\n

Jekk hu hekk, dan mhux biss huwa mod redikolu ta’ kif titmexxa l-politika. Huwa wkoll mod korrott.<\/p>\n

Sinjifikat ie\u0127or kemmxejn mo\u0127bi fl-istqarrija ta’ Bernard Grech dwar ir-retorika ta’ “Maltin kontra barranin” hu dik ta’ kif fisser stqarrija uffi\u010bjali tal-PN b\u0127ala retorika. Ma riedx ifisser retorika fis-sens klassiku tal-kelma. Ried ifisser it-tifsira li \u0127adet dik il-kelma llum: ji\u0121ifieri vojta, populista, provokattiva, li tkebbes emozzjonijiet negattivi, tippunta subg\u0127ajha lejn l-o\u0127rajn u tipprovoka l-mibg\u0127eda. Seta’ fa\u010bilment u\u017ca l-kelma ‘faxxista’.<\/p>\n

B’dik id-dikjarazzjoni tieg\u0127u, Grech waqqa’ l-proposti li g\u0127amlu Giglio u Borg g\u0127al-livell ta’ retorika. Din, wara kollox, ma kinitx politika mfassla. Kienu biss paroli. Paroli li tista’ ssej\u0127ilhom perikolu\u017ci.<\/p>\n

Kliem Bernard Grech wie\u0127ed jista’ j\u0127ares lejhom minn \u017cew\u0121 na\u0127at. Tista’ tistqarr li g\u0127andu s-sa\u0127\u0127a jwaqqa’ l-kelma ta’ \u017cew\u0121 membri parlamentari tal-partit tieg\u0127u li ma \u017cammewx mal-linja tal-partit, billi b’mod pubbliku \u010b\u010bara li diskors razzist ma jaqbilx mal-valuri tal-partit tieg\u0127u. M’g\u0127andix dubju li Bernard Grech stenna li kliemu hekk kellu jinftiehem mill-pubbliku. Mhux biss, i\u017cda l-pubbliku kien ikollu jag\u0127raf il-kura\u0121\u0121 ta’ Bernard Grech li jwaqqa’ stqarrija li setg\u0127et tkebbes rabja pubblika u dan minflok tirba\u0127 l-appo\u0121\u0121 immedjat tal-pubbliku. Fi kliem ie\u0127or, qadef kontra l-kurrent biex jag\u0127mel dak li hu sewwa.<\/p>\n

G\u0127aldaqstant, jekk trid tkun po\u017cittiv u tfittex xi ra\u0121uni li tittama li l-PN g\u0127adu mmexxi minn persuni pjuttost bilan\u010bjati u demokrati\u010bi, Bernard Grech tak ma xiex tiggranfa.<\/p>\n

Personalment, lili ftit li xejn impressjonani. G\u0127al darb’o\u0127ra, l-PN qed jistedinna biex dak li jistqarr il-Partit ma nie\u0127du\u0127x bis-serjet\u00e0 u dan spe\u010bjalment meta Joe Giglio jkun qed jitkellem f’ismu. L-a\u0127\u0127ar darba li \u0121rat \u0127a\u0121a b\u0127al din, Joe Giglio kien pubblikament wera l-istmerrija g\u0127all-whistleblower<\/em> li kienet il-ka\u0121un tal-g\u0127eluq tal-klijent tieg\u0127u: ji\u0121ifieri l-Pilatus Bank<\/em>. U kien stqarr ukoll li l-kelma ta’ g\u0127aqdiet tas-so\u010bjet\u00e0 \u010bivili ma kellhiex pi\u017c daqs\u00a0 il-kelma ta’ politiku.<\/p>\n

Wara li ra li l-istqarrija tieg\u0127u kienet bell\u0127et lil bosta persuni, Joe Giglio bil\u0121ri qal li kien qieg\u0127ed biss jesprimi l-opinjoni personali tieg\u0127u u mhux il-linja uffi\u010bjali tal-Partit.<\/p>\n

Ftit aktar diffi\u010bli li issa tkejjel bl-istess riga, hux hekk? Joe Giglio ma kienx qed ilablab f’xi intervista fuq ir-radju. Kien qed jitkellem dwar stqarrija tal-PN. Stqarrija uffi\u010bjali u formali li wie\u0127ed g\u0127andu jifhem li tkun ixxandret bil-barka tal-Partit li jkun xandarha. U ma kienx wa\u0127du g\u0127aliex Alex Borg iffirma l-istqarrija mieg\u0127u.<\/p>\n

Wara li Joe Giglio kien tkellem f’dik il-famu\u017ca intervista, jien kont g\u0127idt li ma stajtx nifhem kif il-PN jista’ jippretendi li a\u0127na – ji\u0121ifieri l-pubbliku – se nkunu nafu l-Membri Parlamentari tieg\u0127u jkunux qed jitkellmu f’isem il-Partit jew f’isimhom personali. Importanti li nkunu nafu fi\u010b-\u010bert l-politika tal-Partit x’inhi g\u0127aliex b’hekk biss inkunu nistg\u0127u nistennew li l-politi\u010bi li nkunu vvutajna g\u0127alihom se jimxu fuq dawk il-prin\u010bipji fil-Parlament jew, xi darba, meta jew jekk isiru Ministri.<\/p>\n

Tal-inqas Joe Giglio jkun, u g\u0127andu kull intenzjoni li jsir, il-ministru tal-intern. Se jimxi skont il-fehma personali tieg\u0127u li ju\u017ca lill-armata fit toroq b’ordnijiet li jke\u010b\u010bu barranin li g\u0127andhom karna\u0121jon skur b’mod li sa issa huwa kkunsidrat b\u0127ala wie\u0127ed ina\u010b\u010bettabbli? Jekk jinxtered id-demm, Bernard Grech kemm ser ikollu l-\u0127ila li jserr\u0127ilna rasna – kemm il-darba jsir Prim Ministru – li hu ma jaqbilx mal-im\u0121ieba jew mal-kliem li jkun stqarr ministru minn tieg\u0127u?<\/p>\n

Li kieku Joe Giglio u Alex Borg g\u0127amlu u\u017cu mill-infrastruttura tal-PN, minn ismu u mill-kredenzjali tieg\u0127u biex jistqarru l-fehmiet personali tag\u0127hom u r-retorika razzista tag\u0127hom, Bernard Grech, b\u0127ala kap tal-oppo\u017cizzjoni, kien ikollu d-dmir li mhux jilmenta biss. Nista’ nilmenta jien. Kif fil-fatt g\u0127amilt.<\/p>\n

Il-politika ta’ partit ma tixxejjinx g\u0127ax hekk ikun jixtieq xi \u0127add, anki meta dak ix-xi \u0127add jinzerta li hu kelliem tal-partit. Fi \u0127danu l-partit membri, strutturi, gruppi, kumitati u xibkiet formali u informali. Jekk Joe Giglio u Alex Grech qab\u017cu lil dawn kollha sabiex jimponu l-fehmiet tag\u0127hom fuq il-Partit, g\u0127andu jkun hemm konsegwenzi g\u0127al dan. Frankament, il-Kap tal-Oppo\u017cizzjoni g\u0127andu jdabbrilhom rashom.<\/p>\n

Ir-realt\u00e0 turi mod ie\u0127or. Ejja nkunu onesti. L-istrutturi li suppost qed ikebbsu d-dibattiti u jfasslu politika m’g\u0127adhomx je\u017cistu. M’hemmx dibattitu politiku li jinvolvi l-membri tal-partit. Ix-xibkiet formali u nformali tal-partit – fejn dawn je\u017cistu – mo\u0127\u0127hom biss f’\u0127a\u0121a wa\u0127da: kif se jibqg\u0127u \u0127ajjin u jevitaw il-falliment.<\/p>\n

Ma hemm \u0127add li jista’ jimmodera fehmiet potenzjalment estremisti jew spontanji u li jiddiskuti x’jaf ikun l-effett tag\u0127hom u jo\u0127oro\u0121 bi strate\u0121iji alternattivi. G\u0127alhekk ir-retorika tispi\u010b\u010ba to\u0127ro\u0121 minn mo\u0127\u0127 membru parlamentari li rrea\u0121ixxa g\u0127all-filmat li xxandar fil-mezzi so\u010bjali u pin\u0121a kliemu b\u0127allikieku dawn kienu l-politika uffi\u010bjali tal-PN. Ka\u0121un tal-fatt li x-xibka formali jew informali biex timmodera hi nieqsa.<\/p>\n

Bl-istess mod, diffi\u010bli wie\u0127ed ig\u0127id Bernard Grech huwiex i\u0121ib ru\u0127u skont il-prin\u010bipji tal-Partit g\u0127aliex, b\u0127al u daqs Giglio u Borg, m’g\u0127andux g\u0127ad-dispo\u017cizzjoni tieg\u0127u grupp ta’ persuni li jista’ jg\u0127addilu l-fehmiet.<\/p>\n

Dan ma jfissirx li l-PN sar partit lemini-estrem mag\u0127mul biss minn persuni li g\u0127andhom \u0121ilda bajda. I\u017cda s-suspett hemm qieg\u0127ed.<\/p>\n

Fid-de\u017cert lis-suldati wie\u0127ed jista’ jarahom javvi\u010binaw anki minn distanza twila. I\u017cda jkun diffi\u010bli tag\u0127raf jekk dawn ikunux \u0127bieb jew g\u0127edewwa.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"

Ikkritikajt lil Joe Giglio u, b’mod impli\u010bitu lil Alex Borg, g\u0127all-istqarrija li \u0127are\u0121 il-PN u li permezz tag\u0127ha ppropona li biex jinstab tarf g\u0127all-problemi marbutin mas-sigurt\u00e0 fil-pajji\u017c, je\u0127tie\u0121 li b’mod “immedjat” jitke\u010b\u010bew dawk il-barranin li jwettqu delitt u jiksru l-li\u0121ijiet tal-pajji\u017c. Il-kliem vag u iebes u n-natura intrinsikament diskriminatorja ta’ din l-istqarrija turi li hi […]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":111229,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":[],"categories":[54],"tags":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/111232\/"}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post\/"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1\/"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments\/?post=111232"}],"version-history":[{"count":5,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/111232\/revisions\/"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":111295,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/111232\/revisions\/111295\/"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/111229\/"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/?parent=111232"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories\/?post=111232"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags\/?post=111232"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}