Illum il-Qorti \u010ba\u0127det l-ilment ta’ Adrian Delia li meta l-Avukat \u0120enerali rrifjuta li jg\u0127addilu kopja tar-rapport tal-inkjesta Egrant<\/a>, kien \u010ba\u0127adlu d-dritt li jesprimi ru\u0127u b\u0127ala l-g\u0127assies tal-gvern u ddiskrimina kontrih g\u0127aliex ta trattament differenti lill-Partit Laburista minn dak li ng\u0127ata lill-Partit Nazzjonalista.<\/p>\nAdrian Delia qal li bi \u0127siebu jappella mis-sentenza.<\/p>\n
G\u0127alkemm huwa interessanti, d-dibattitu legali qed ise\u0127\u0127 fl-assenza ta’ dibattitu politiku adegwat.<\/p>\n
Il-li\u0121i suppost g\u0127andha tg\u0127odd g\u0127al kul\u0127add bl-istess mod, kemm jekk wie\u0127ed ikun qed jokkupa kariga pubblika u kemm jekk le. Fil-prin\u010bipju, dan huwa intenzjonat biex ji\u017cgura li s-setg\u0127ana ma jing\u0127atawx preferenzi fuq \u0127addie\u0127or. Il-qorti suppost m’g\u0127andha t\u0127ares lejn wi\u010b\u010b ebda wie\u0127ed minn dawk li jirrikorru g\u0127andha, i\u017cda g\u0127andha te\u017camina l-fatti u tapplika dak li tg\u0127id il-li\u0121i.<\/p>\n
Jien m’jinix kwalifikat bi\u017c\u017cejjed biex nifhem l-argumenti li \u0121ab il-Kap tal-Oppo\u017cizzjoni jew il-motivazzjoni tal-qorti fin-nuqqas ta’ qbil tag\u0127ha ma’ dawn l-argumenti: ma nistax ng\u0127id il-qorti kellhiex ra\u0121un jew le f’dak li dde\u010bidiet.<\/p>\n
I\u017cda nista’ ng\u0127id li g\u0127andu jew m’g\u0127andux ra\u0121un legali l-Kap tal-Oppo\u017cizzjoni li jitlob kopja tar-rapport, dan \u017cgur li g\u0127andu ra\u0121un li jitolbu – jekk mhux g\u0127an-nom tieg\u0127u stess – g\u0127an-nom ta’ kul\u0127add.<\/p>\n
L-Avukat \u0120enerali ammetta li kien hemm mi\u017cura partikolari ta’ interess pubbliku fil-ka\u017c. Din ma kienitx inkjesta dwar l-im\u0121ieba \u0127a\u017cina ta’ xi \u0127add kwalunkwe i\u017cda inkjesta dwar l-allegata m\u0121ieba \u0127a\u017cina tal-Prim Ministru attwali – l-istess persuna li kien fil-kariga meta se\u0127\u0127et l-allegata m\u0121ieba \u0127a\u017cina, meta saret l-inkjesta u meta ntemmet l-inkjesta.<\/p>\n
Kien Peter Grech li dde\u010bieda wa\u0127du sa fejn g\u0127andu jwassal l-interess pubbliku. Skont il-fehma tieg\u0127u, l-g\u0127a\u017cla li jxandar biss 49 pa\u0121na \u2013 lejn it-tmiem, i\u017cda mhux il-pa\u0121ni tal-a\u0127\u0127ar ta’ inkjesta twila 1,500 pa\u0121na – kienet bi\u017c\u017cejjed biex tissodisfa l-interess pubbliku.<\/p>\n
Din m’g\u0127o\u0121bitx biss lil Adrian Delia. Ironikament, g\u0127al ftit ta\u017c-\u017cmien, Adrian Delia deher li kien sodisfatt tant li g\u0127amel u\u017cu minn dawk id-49 pa\u0121na b\u0127ala ra\u0121uni biex ike\u010b\u010bi lil Simon Busuttil mill-kariga ta’ kelliem dwar il-governanza tajba u li jitlob l-awto-sospensjoni tieg\u0127u.<\/p>\n
X’aktarx li ma nfluwenzatx lill-qorti d-dawra durella li spi\u010b\u010ba g\u0127amel Adrian Delia meta beda’ jinsisti g\u0127al kopja tar-rapport s\u0127i\u0127 biex seta’ jasal g\u0127al \u0121udizzju politiku.<\/p>\n
Madankollu din id-dawra durella g\u0127amlet \u0127sara lill-argument politiku g\u0127aliex, tg\u0127id x’tg\u0127id il-li\u0121i dwar id-“dritt” ta’ Kap tal-Oppo\u017cizzjoni, fl-a\u0127\u0127ar mill-a\u0127\u0127ar din hi kwistjoni politika u fil-qasam politiku il-li\u0121i ma tapplikax bl-istess mod g\u0127al kul\u0127add.<\/p>\n
Din l-anqas m’hi kwistjoni “ta’ livell aktar g\u0127oli” ta’ \u0121udizzju g\u0127all-politi\u010bi.<\/p>\n
M’hemmx l-i\u010bken dubju li fost l-ambjenti politi\u010bi je\u017cistu suspetti li dak li ma xxandarx mir-rapport tal-inkjesta Egrant jista’ jikka\u0121una \u0127sara kbira \u0127afna kemm lill-Prim Ministru kif ukoll lil istituzzjonijiet o\u0127ra b\u0127alma huma l-Avukat \u0120enerali u l-Pulizija u dan talli dawn setg\u0127u naqsu li ja\u0121ixxu fuq dak li rri\u017culta mir-rapport tal-inkjesta.<\/p>\n
L-elf u \u0127ames mitt pa\u0121na ma ttrattawx biss dwar in-nuqqas ta’ provi li kellhom jikkonfermaw li sid l-Egrant huwa Joseph Muscat.<\/p>\n
Irri\u017culta mill-provi sid l-Egrant min hu?<\/p>\n
Fuq kollox, il-qofol tal-kwistjoni m’huwiex dwar sid l-Egrant min hu. Filwaqt li minn banda, g\u0127al Joseph Muscat ma \u0121ara’ assolutament xejn li Konrad Mizzi u Keith Schembri nqabdu b’kumpanniji sigrieti fil-Panama u li din ma kinitx ra\u0121uni bi\u017c\u017cejjed biex idabbrilhom rashom, mill-banda l-o\u0127ra ji\u0121i b’\u0127afna melodrama dwar dik li, skont hu, hi akku\u017ca falza li hu sid wa\u0127da minn dawn il-kumpanniji sigrieti.<\/p>\n
Kull twe\u0121iba alternattiva g\u0127ax-xilja li \u2018Muscat huwa sid l-Egrant\u2019 g\u0127andu jkollha l-effett li tillibera lil Joseph Muscat fuq ba\u017ci personali u kriminali. I\u017cda je\u017cistu twe\u0121ibiet o\u0127rajn li xorta wa\u0127da jistg\u0127u j\u0121ieg\u0127luh i\u0127allas prezz politiku.<\/p>\n
Filwaqt li qed jag\u0127mel tabirru\u0127u li jixtieq r-rapport tal-inkjesta jixxandar, ftit huma dawk li qed jemmnu dan it-teatrin li jinqala’ \u0127afna g\u0127alih. G\u0127al \u0121img\u0127at s\u0127a\u0127, qalulna li d-dokument kien qed ji\u0121i redatt \u2013 mhux mill-Avukat \u0120enerali tafux – i\u017cda mill-avukati personali ta’ Joseph Muscat li g\u0127andhom l-istess interessi li g\u0127andu hu.<\/p>\n
Sakemm kollox jibqa’ ta\u0127t il-kontroll tieg\u0127u, ir-rapport Egrant mhux se jara d-dawl tax-xemx. Filwaqt li bid-diskors ig\u0127idilna li jixtieqna naqrawh, bil-fatti qed ja\u0127bih: qisu dak il-qattiel li lill-pulizija jurihom id-debba tal-koperazzjoni u mbag\u0127ad iqabb\u017cilhom il-\u0127mara tat-tfixkil minn ta\u0127t.<\/p>\n
Din m’hix kwistjoni dwar jekk hemmx ra\u0121un legali jew le. Il-Prim Ministru huwa kontabbli mhux biss fil-konfront tal-Im\u0127allfin, tal-Parlament u tal-Kap tal-Oppo\u017cizzjoni.<\/p>\n
Huwa wkoll kontabbli lejn il-poplu. G\u0127andu f’idejh rapport li hu jaf x’fih. Huwa jaf sid l-Egrant min hu u ma jridx jikxef dak li jaf.<\/p>\n
Issa tard wisq biex wie\u0127ed joqg\u0127od jilmenta li l-Prim Ministru – li kien is-su\u0121\u0121ett tal-inkjesta\u00a0 – ma messux ing\u0127ata kopja tar-rapport Egrant. Peter Grech le\u0127aq g\u0127axxaqha f’dan ir-rigward.<\/p>\n
Din m’hix kwistjoni ta’ “dritt” li a\u0127na jista’ jkollna li naqraw ir-rapport s\u0127i\u0127 biex b’hekk ikun hemm bilan\u010b ma’ dak li jaf il-Partit Laburista. G\u0127andna “dritt” li naqraw ir-rapport s\u0127i\u0127 g\u0127aliex Joseph Muscat suppost huwa l-qaddej\u00a0 – mhux is-sultan – tag\u0127na, u b\u0127ala sidien tieg\u0127u g\u0127andna g\u0127alxiex mhux biss li nit\u0127assbu dwar l-integrit\u00e0 tieg\u0127u meta jew jekk jirri\u017culta li \u0127oloq kumpannija fil-Panama f’isem martu biex tir\u010bievi flus \u0121ejjin mit-tix\u0127im ming\u0127and id-dittatur tal-A\u017cerbaj\u0121an.<\/p>\n
Messu dabbar rasu fuq ferm inqas minn hekk. Sa\u0127ansitra messu warrab anki fuq ix-xtur li g\u0127atta dwar min tassew huwa sid l-Egrant u dwar il-bsaten fir-roti li saru biex tibqa’ ma ssirx \u0121ustizzja mal-\u0127allelin li qed ja\u0127kmu lill-pajji\u017c.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"
Illum il-Qorti \u010ba\u0127det l-ilment ta’ Adrian Delia li meta l-Avukat \u0120enerali rrifjuta li jg\u0127addilu kopja tar-rapport tal-inkjesta Egrant, kien \u010ba\u0127adlu d-dritt li jesprimi ru\u0127u b\u0127ala l-g\u0127assies tal-gvern u ddiskrimina kontrih g\u0127aliex ta trattament differenti lill-Partit Laburista minn dak li ng\u0127ata lill-Partit Nazzjonalista. Adrian Delia qal li bi \u0127siebu jappella mis-sentenza. G\u0127alkemm huwa interessanti, d-dibattitu legali […]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":74689,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":[],"categories":[54],"tags":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/74692\/"}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post\/"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1\/"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments\/?post=74692"}],"version-history":[{"count":5,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/74692\/revisions\/"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":74779,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/74692\/revisions\/74779\/"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/74689\/"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/?parent=74692"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories\/?post=74692"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/mt\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags\/?post=74692"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}
![\"\"](\"https:\/\/manueldelia.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2019\/05\/Muscat-Joseph-1.jpg\")
<\/p>\n